Losing customers is more than just a revenue loss—it can negatively impact your brand’s reputation and future sales. Dissatisfied customers are more vocal than satisfied ones, with Americans sharing a poor service experience with an average of 15 people, compared to 11 people for a positive experience¹. On social media, this dissatisfaction spreads even further, damaging a company’s credibility and influencing potential buyers.
However, there’s a silver lining—winning back lost customers can be easier and more cost-effective than acquiring new ones. According to Harvard Business Review, these customers have already shown interest in your product or service, making them better candidates than cold leads². They also recognize your brand, so there’s no need for an introduction, reducing the effort required to bring them back.
How to Win Back Your Lost Customers
1. Understand Why They Left
A staggering 69% of customers leave because they feel undervalued³. The first step to winning them back is to show that you care.
Steps to take:
-
Analyze past interactions using CRM, marketing automation, and sales databases.
-
Identify patterns in their journey, including past purchases and engagement frequency.
-
Utilize social listening tools to track feedback they may have shared online.
A data-driven approach ensures that when you reconnect, you can personalize the conversation and address their concerns effectively.
2. Reconnect and Rebuild Trust
Once you have insights into why the customer left, reach out through the right channel—phone, email, social media, or even an in-person meeting.
Best practices:
-
Listen carefully and show empathy toward their concerns.
-
Identify whether the issue was situational (one-time problem) or systemic (recurring issue).
-
Determine whether the cost of re-engagement justifies the effort.
-
Offer a clear resolution or incentive to encourage their return.
A well-handled approach can turn a previously lost customer into a loyal advocate.
3. Stay in Touch and Nurture the Relationship
Even if you don’t immediately win them back, it’s essential to keep the connection alive. Many lost customers still:
-
Have an active opt-in for emails or marketing materials.
-
Engage with your brand online, giving you opportunities to re-engage through personalized offers.
By leveraging predictive analytics, businesses can anticipate their evolving needs and reach out at the right moment with the right offer.
Measuring the Value of Returning Customers
Not all lost customers are worth regaining. Businesses must evaluate their Customer Second-Lifetime Value (CSLTV)—the potential revenue generated after a customer is won back.
-
If the cost of reacquisition exceeds the CSLTV, the strategy may not be profitable.
-
If the returning customer’s needs and spending potential have increased, they could be highly valuable for long-term profitability⁵.
Winning back lost customers requires a balance of effort, timing, and the right strategy. A customer-centric, data-driven approach ensures that businesses can successfully re-engage former customers and drive sustained growth.
References
[1] https://www.helpscout.net/75-customer-service-facts-quotes-statistics/
[2] https://hbr.org/2016/03/winning-back-lost-customers
[3] http://www.visualcapitalist.com/customers-leaving-can-win-back/
[4] https://www.inc.com/geoffrey-james/how-to-win-a-customer-back.html
